CT identified wooden foreign material in 9 of 30 dogs with acute oropharyngeal stick injuries

A UK referral center reviewed 30 dogs imaged within 7 days of injury; post-contrast series and wide window settings improved detection of small fragments.

CT identified wooden foreign material in 9 of 30 dogs with acute oropharyngeal stick injuries

Photo: Quilia · Unsplash

A retrospective study of 30 dogs presenting with acute oropharyngeal stick injuries found that computed tomography identified wooden foreign material in 9 cases (30.0%), with sensitivity of 69.2% and specificity of 100.0% for detecting retained wood. The study, conducted at a UK referral center, reviewed cases from 2010 to 2020 in which dogs were imaged within 7 days of injury.

What the study found

According to the study, "CT identified wooden foreign material in 9 of 30 dogs (30.0%)." The most common secondary imaging features were lymph node enlargement (27 dogs, 90.0%), "cervical emphysema (n = 26, 86.7%), pneumomediastinum (n = 14, 46.7%), and contrast enhancement of the penetrating injury tract" (13 dogs, 43.3%), the authors report.

The study reports that "three dogs (10.0%) with no distinct wooden foreign material fragments visible on CT displayed mineral-attenuating foci along the tract. Intraoral exploration, endoscopy or surgery subsequently confirmed these as retained wooden fragments." One additional "dog with a 15 mm length stick was CT-negative," according to the paper. The authors classified these four dogs as false negatives.

The study found that "post-contrast images improved detection of stick material when compared to pre-contrast images only." The authors report that "a positive Hounsfield unit (HU) attenuation value (>0 HU) along a suspected injury tract was associated with small stick fragments (< 20 mm) or mineral-attenuating foci (n = 12; Fisher's exact test, p = 0.015)."

How the study was built

This was a single-center retrospective study. According to the paper, "medical records of dogs presenting between January 2010 and December 2020 at a referral center in the United Kingdom were searched for oropharyngeal stick injuries." Dogs were included if owners identified "a specific incident of observed or suspected oropharyngeal stick injury within 7 days prior to presentation" and the dog subsequently underwent "CT imaging within 7 days of the injury," the authors report.

All dogs underwent examination or surgical exploration of the injury tract, esophagus, or both following CT imaging. A single European board-certified radiologist reviewed the CT studies retrospectively, blinded to clinical findings and outcomes.

The authors report that "CT scans were performed using either a 16-slice" or 64-slice multidetector row CT "to acquire images of the head, neck and thorax" with or without abdomen. According to the paper, "slice thickness was 0.625 mm on both systems," and "contrast medium was administered at the radiologist's discretion."

This is a retrospective observational study of imaging findings in dogs that presented to one referral center. It describes associations between CT features and confirmed foreign material, but cannot establish that any imaging feature predicts clinical outcome.

The number, and its error bars

The study reports that CT sensitivity "for detecting wooden foreign bodies in acute cases" was 69.2% (95% CI 38.6 to 90.9%) and specificity was 100.0% (95% CI 80.5 to 100.0%). Positive predictive value was 100.0% and negative predictive value was 81.0%. According to the authors, "unclear CT findings were classified as CT-negative when calculating diagnostic performance." The association between positive Hounsfield unit attenuation value (greater than 0 HU) and small stick fragments or mineral-attenuating foci had a p-value of 0.015 (Fisher's exact test).

What the authors say it cannot tell you

The authors state that "this study represents a secondary analysis of a previously described patient cohort" and that "while prior work evaluated management of acute stick injuries with rigid endoscopy, this current study uses an established dataset to investigate the use of CT." The paper does not state other limitations explicitly.

Who paid for it

The paper does not state funding sources or conflicts of interest.

What this means for your practice

VeterinaryPracticeNow's read, not the study's. Everything in this section is our editorial interpretation for practice owners. The study does not claim any of it.

A negative CT does not rule out retained wood in the acute stick-injury dog, and the discharge conversation with the owner needs to reflect that. Roughly one in three dogs with retained foreign material will have a CT that shows secondary signs (gas, lymph node enlargement, tract enhancement) but no visible stick. If your radiologist or the referral center calls the CT negative or unclear, the owner needs to know upfront that further exploration may still be warranted. When CT does show wood, it is wood, so you can plan the retrieval without second-guessing the image.

If your practice has in-house CT, the authors recommend that "acquiring pre- and post-contrast series and reviewing images with wide lung and standard bone windows may improve detection." That is a protocol question for your radiologist, not a standing order, but it is worth the conversation before the next stick case walks in. If you refer imaging out, ask whether post-contrast series were acquired and whether the study was reviewed in multiple window settings. The answer changes how much weight you put on a negative read.

If your week runs on calls like this one, subscribe to VeterinaryPracticeNow.

For practices that do not have CT, this study sharpens the referral criteria. The dog that is drooling blood but eating normally may still have a small fragment the exam does not find, and the imaging at the referral center may not find it either. The clinical decision is whether to refer based on history and secondary signs, not whether to wait for a definitive CT read. The study's four false negatives (three with mineral-attenuating foci and one with a small stick) were all caught on exploration, which argues for a low threshold to scope the tract even when imaging is unremarkable.

Get the next issue in your inbox. Free, weekly, no fluff.

Unsubscribe anytime.

Source: Frontiers in Veterinary Science ↗

← Back to the Newsdesk